- Luci Money Moves
- Posts
- Lease vs. Buy: Your No-Sweat Guide to Getting Your Next Car
Lease vs. Buy: Your No-Sweat Guide to Getting Your Next Car
Spoiler: There's no single right answer. But there's a right answer for you. Let's find it with a simple analogy everyone gets: your phone plan.

The Eternal Question (That’s Way Less Scary Than It Seems)
Hey there! So you’re thinking about a new set of wheels. Exciting! But then the dreaded question hits: Should you lease or buy? Cue the finance-y jargon and sweaty palms. 😅
Relax. Let’s simplify this.
Leasing is like signing up for the “Upgrade Every 2-3 Years” phone plan. You get the shiny new thing regularly, but you never actually own it.
Buying is like buying your phone outright (even if you use a loan, also known as financing). It’s yours forever, for better or for worse… ‘til death (or a major transmission failure) do you part.
Let’s break down the perks and pitfalls of each “plan,” so you can walk into the dealership feeling like a boss.

Find What Your Looking For Here
Wait, Why Do Car Companies Want Me to Lease?
Great question! It’s not just out of the kindness of their hearts. Leasing is a win-win for them:
They Make More Money: They get a reliable stream of lightly-used, well-maintained cars back that they can sell as Certified Pre-Owned (CPO) vehicles—often for a hefty profit.
They Lock You In: You’re more likely to return to the same brand every 3 years to get another new lease, creating a loyal customer for life.
It’s All About Inertia: Let’s be real—once you learn the infotainment system and quirks of a brand, switching feels like a hassle. If you don’t have a majorly bad experience, you’re less likely to spend the time and effort to research and test-drive a whole new brand. Leasing capitalizes on this perfectly.
The Ultimate “Try Before You… Well, Just Try” Model: And if you don’t end up loving the car you’re leasing? No problem! It’s not yours forever. You just have to wait it out, and the dealership gets another shot to win you over with a newer, shinier model in a few years. This low-commitment vibe is everyone’s dream and is a huge part of why leasing is so enticing.
Think of it like a subscription service: they love the recurring revenue and the customer loyalty it builds! Now, back to your options…
Plan A: The “Always Shiny” Upgrade Plan (Leasing)
Imagine a new car every few years, like clockwork. This is that.
The Perks: Why It’s So Tempting
Lower Monthly “Subscription” Fee: You’re only paying for the car’s steepest depreciation (the value it loses in the first few years), not the whole enchilada. This usually means a lower monthly payment than a loan.
Permanent New-Car Smell: Get a new ride with the latest tech, safety features, and that irresistible smell every few years. You’re always driving the current model.
The “Bubble Wrap” Warranty: Major repairs are almost always covered under the manufacturer’s warranty. It’s like having a permanent AppleCare—peace of mind is included.
The "Uh-Ohs": The Fine Print
The Mileage “Data Cap”: Leases come with an annual mileage limit (usually 10,000-15,000 miles). Go over, and you’ll face pricey overage fees—like getting charged for roaming or extra data on your phone.
You’re Just Renting Vibe: After all your payments, you hand the keys back. You’ve built zero equity. It’s a long-term rental, not a path to ownership.
Fear the Dent: Return the car with more than “normal wear and tear” (think: big dents, stained upholstery, curbed wheels) and you’ll get a bill for the “damages.”
Plan B: The “Slow & Steady” Ownership Plan (Buying)
This is the long game. It requires patience upfront, but it can pay off big time.
The Perks: Ultimate Freedom
The Glorious Day of No Payments: Once the loan is paid off (typically in 4-6 years), you own it free and clear. That monthly payment vanishing from your budget is a massive financial win.
Unlimited “Data” for Life: Drive cross-country every weekend? Go for it. Want to add quirky bumper stickers? It’s your canvas. No one can charge you for living your life how you want.
You’re Building an Asset: Even though the car loses value massively, you can sell it or trade it in later. That’s money back in your pocket—something that never happens with a lease.
The "Uh-Ohs": The Responsibility
Higher Monthly Payments: You’re paying for the entire car, so your monthly payments are usually higher than a lease for a similar vehicle.
BFFs With Your Mechanic: After the warranty expires, every repair bill lands squarely in your lap. Oil changes are one thing; a new transmission is WHOLE ‘NOTHER THING.
The “D” Word (Depreciation): A new car’s value drops the fastest in the first few years—as soon as you drive your new car off the lot, it loses between 9% and 11% of its value…yikes. Generally, buying is considered the more economical choice if you keep the car long after the loan is paid off.
Pro Tip: Some cars hold their value much better than others (think Toyota, Honda, Subaru), so if you plan to resell, that’s a huge factor to consider!
Sidebar: To My Favorite Story About Cars
Okay, real quick—I have to share one of my all-time favorite car stories that proves how crazy reliable some cars can be.
Meet the legendary Toyota Tacoma that drove over 1.6 MILLION miles. (Yeah, you read that right. That’s like driving to the Moon and back…about SEVEN times.)
The owner, a guy named Mike Neal, used it for his medical supply delivery job. He basically lived in that truck, and thanks to obsessive maintenance and Toyota’s famously stubborn reliability, it just kept going…and going…and going. It became such a legend that when Mike eventually retired it, Toyota themselves asked for the truck back to put it on display!
It’s the ultimate proof that if you pick the right ride and take proper care of it, buying a car isn’t just a purchase, it’s a long-term partnership that can literally go the distance.
The Sneaky Fine Print You MUST Read
(This is where they get ya! Don’t skip this.)
The Universal Rule:
⛔️ No matter which path you choose, you are legally required to have car insurance. This is a non-negotiable cost that must be factored into your monthly budget for both leasing and buying. Leasing companies often require more comprehensive coverage, so get quotes beforehand!
For Leasing:
⛔️ Disposition Fee: A charge for turning the car in at the end. Ask if it can be waived if you lease another car from the same brand.
⛔️ Gap Insurance: Crucial! If a leased car is totaled, your insurance might not cover what you still owe the leasing company. Gap insurance covers that “gap.” Often included, but always confirm it.
For Buying:
⛔️ The Interest Rate Is King: A lower rate = saving thousands. Your credit score is the key to unlocking the best rates. Shop around for loans from banks or credit unions before you go to the dealer.
Quick Quiz: Which "Plan" Is Your Soulmate? 🤔
(Be honest with yourself!)
Lease if you...
→ Geek out and get a thrill from the latest tech, features, and that sweet new car smell.
→ Drive a predictable, lower number of miles (city dwellers, we see you).
→ Break into a cold sweat at the thought of surprise repair bills.
Buy if you...
→ Dream of the day you have ZERO car payments.
→ Drive a lot, love good spontaneous road trips, or have a long commute.
→ See your car as a long-term partner and want the freedom to customize it.
The Final Lap 🏁
So, what’s the verdict? It’s one of those things where there isn’t a choice that is “better.” It’s figuring out what’s better for you and your situation.
Here’s the economic reality: While leasing gives you lower monthly payments upfront, buying is almost always more economical in the long run. Once you pay off that loan you own an asset (even if it’s depreciated) and enjoy years of payment-free driving. Constantly leasing means you’ll always have a car payment and never build equity. The best choice is an informed one! You’ve got this! Get those sweet new wheels, and I’ll see you next week. Cheers, Mitch — Luci Money Moves Newsletter | ![]() This could be you! |
|
PS: Seriously, that buffer in your checking account. Do it. Your peace of mind will thank you later.
PPS: Loved this? Please share it with a friend who needs to put their finances on autopilot!
Reply