Luci Money Moves
Posts
The Retirement Account Heavyweight Bout 🥊

The Retirement Account Heavyweight Bout 🥊

In this corner: the 401(k) with its employer entourage! And in this corner: the independent IRA! We're calling the rounds to crown the champion for YOUR money.

Richard Yoon
October 22, 2025

🗣️🎙️Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to the main event of the financial world! Tonight, two titans of retirement enter the ring. In one corner, The Corporate Champion, by a powerful employer…and in the other, The People’s Champ, a master of flexibility and choice… LET’S GET READY TO RUMBLEEE!

Check This Out Cookie Monster GIF by Sesame Street

Find What Your Looking For Here

🎙️ LET'S GET STARTED

🚨 THE WEIGH-IN: MEET YOUR CONTENDERS 💪

Ladies and the gentlest-of-men! Before the first bell rings, let’s size up our two financial heavyweights.

🔵 IN THE BLUE CORNER: “THE CORPORATE CHAMPION” THE 401(K)

🥊 Fighting Out Of: Corporate America

🏆️ Manager: Your Employer

🏋️ Training Regiment: Automatic payroll deductions. This contender is all about discipline—the money is gone before you even see your paycheck.

🎯 Fight Strategy: Win by consistency and powerful corporate backing.

⚖️ Weight Class: The Company Man - Built for stability and employer support.

❝

This fighter doesn’t need flashy moves—just consistent, automated contributions that build wealth while you sleep.

🔴 IN THE RED CORNER: “THE PEOPLE’S CHAMP” THE IRA

🥊 Fighting Out Of: Your Personal Initiative

🏆️ Manager: YOU! (via financial brokers like Vanguard, Fidelity, or Charles Schwab)

🏋️ Training Regiment: Self-directed contributions. You decide when, how much, and where the money goes.

🎯 Fight Strategy: Win through flexibility, unlimited choice, and sheer independence.

⚖️ Weight Class: The Lone Desperado - Built for maximum control and customization.

❝

This contender answers to no one but you. Total freedom, total control—but you’ve got to call all the shots.

📣 AND IN THE CENTER OF THE RING…

👨🏽‍💼THE REF (That’s Me! Your Luci Money Moves Editor): “Alright, I want a clean fight! No low blows, no hidden fees, and protect yourself at all times. I’ll be here calling the rounds fair and square.

🧑‍⚖️AND IN THE JUDGE’S SEAT IS… YOU!

You’re not just watching from the stands—you’re the head judge with the final scorecards. These two might be facing off, but you’re the one who decides the ultimate winner for your financial future.

❝

Keep your eyes open, judge. Let’s see how they match up in the first round!

🥊 ROUND 1️⃣: THE KNOCKOUT PUNCH

401(k): The Employer Match - This is the haymaker! It’s FREE MONEY - an instant 50-100% return makes the crowd go wild!

TLDR; → This refers to the contributions an employer makes to an employee’s 401(k) plan, typically based on the employee’s own contributions. For example, an employer might match 50% of the employee’s contributions up to a certain percentage of their salary. This is often considered “free money” because it’s additional compensation that employees don’t have to work for beyond their own contributions.

IRA: Total Investment Freedom - Its devastating combo move! Access to nearly any stock, bond, or fund means unlimited flexibility.

❝

REF’S CALL: The 401(k) lands a powerful blow with that match, but the IRA shows incredible finesse with its unlimited options!

🥊 ROUND 2️⃣: THE GLARING WEAKNESS

401(k): The Limited Menu - Your employer chooses the investment options. It’s a curated list when you might want the whole menu.

IRA: No Free Lunch - There’s no employer to match your contributions. You’re fighting solo without that corporate backup.

❝

REF’S CALL: “Both fighters showing vulnerabilities! Who will be the first to take advantage of it? The IRA lacks support, while the 401(k)’s limited freedom leaves it open to counter-attacks.”

🏟️BETWEEN ROUNDS: A WORD FROM THE CORNER CREW

The bell has rung, and the fighters have retreated to their corners. While they recover, let’s get a deeper look at their training and what really makes them tick. This is where the real strategy is built.

CRITICAL CLARIFICATION: Whether it’s a 401(k) or an IRA, these accounts are not investments themselves. Think of them as empty vehicles—like a car. You still have to put fuel in it (your contributions) and drive it somewhere (choose investments like stocks, funds, bonds, commodities, etc.) for it to actually take you anywhere!

🧠The Mental Game: “Tax Now or Tax Later?”

This is the core strategic decision that applies to BOTH of our fighters (401(k)s and IRAs). The million-dollar question: Do you want to pay taxes on your money now or in retirement?

Here’s the bare-bones breakdown:

Feature	Roth (Pay Taxes NOW)	Traditional (Pay Taxes LATER)
The Gist	Pay taxes on the seeds. Harvest the entire crop tax-free. 🌱	Get a tax break on seeds. Pay taxes on the entire harvest later.
Contributions	Post-tax money	Pre-tax money (lowers your taxable income now)
Withdrawals	TAX-FREE in retirement	Taxed as ordinary income
Ideal For	Young earners, people in low tax brackets, and anyone who believes their tax rate will be higher in retirement.	High earners in their peak career years who believe their tax rate will be lower in retirement.

THE REF’S CORNER WISDOM:

Roth Path: Pay taxes now → contributions grow TAX-FREE FOREVER. Peace of mind, and when you retire your account will be truly representative of the money available for withdrawal.
Traditional Path: Tax breaks now on your contributions → pay taxes on everything when you withdraw from your retirement account. Which means you will have more money that can grow in your account but when you retire the tax on the withdrawals may negate that growth.

TLDR; → Roth = pay now, tax-free growth; Traditional = tax break now, pay taxes later.

HOW TO CALL THE SHOT:

The rule of thumb is simple: if you believe you’re in a lower tax bracket today than you will be in retirement, choose Roth. If you’re in your peak earning years and expect a lower income in retirement, a Traditional might be the better bet.

The Luci Verdict: For most people in their 20s and 30s, the Roth option is a champion’s move. You’re likely at your lowest tax bracket now, so locking in a lifetime of tax-free growth is a massive win.

Pro Tip: You can have both! Many people start with Roth when they are young, then add Traditional contributions as their income grows.

🥡THE TALE OF THE TAPE: CONTRIBUTIONS, LIMITS & INCOME RULES

Account Type

2025 Contribution Limit (Under 50)

Key Income (MAGI) Limits for 2025

401(k)

$23,500 (This limit applies to your combined Roth and Traditional 401(k) contributions)

✅ No income limits for contributions.

Anyone with a workplace plan can participate, regardless of how high their salary is.

IRA

$7,000 (This is the combined limit for all your IRAs)

Roth IRA: ❌ Contribution eligibility phases out between $150,000-$165,000 (single) and $236,000-$246,000 (married).

Traditional IRA: ✅ Anyone can contribute. However, the tax deduction phases out if you also have a workplace retirement plan like a 401(k).

TLDR; 🧾 Traditional IRA Tax Deduction Explained

A tax deduction lowers your taxable income. If you contribute $7,000, you subtract it from your income, so you’re taxed on a smaller amount (e.g., $60,000 salary becomes $53,000 for tax purposes). You get a tax break now, but you’ll pay taxes on ordinary income taxes on your withdrawals in retirement.

🧑‍💼 So, how does it work when you have a workplace retirement plan then?

Think of it this way: if you have a 401(k) at work, you already have one tax-advantaged account. The IRS allows you to contribute to a Traditional IRA on top of that, but if your income is high, they start to phase out the amount of your contribution you can deduct from your taxable income for this second account.

Here’s the 2025 rule for single filers that are also covered by a workplace plan:

MAGI below $79,000: You get the full tax deduction for your Traditional IRA contribution.
MAGI between $79,000 and $89,000: You get a partial deduction.
MAGI above $89,000: You get no deduction. You can still contribute, but without the upfront tax break.

If your head is still spinning from this, check out this graphic about Roth IRA Contribution Eligibility vs. Traditional IRA Deduction Eligibilty—2025. I hope this helps you see the bigger picture!

TLDR; 🚫 Why The Roth IRA Phase-Out Exists

The government created this rule because the Roth IRA’s benefit is so powerful. Since you contribute with money you’ve already paid taxes on, your investments get to grow completely tax-free, and qualified withdrawals in retirement are also tax-free. The phase-out limits this perk for high earners.

The Bottom Line:

401(k): Your only limit is the dollar amount.
IRA: It’s all about your income.
- The Roth IRA has an income cap to contribute at all.
- Traditional IRA has an income cap for the tax deduction if you have a workplace plan.

Secret Backdoor Alert! 🚪💨 Hit the Roth income cap? You can contribute to a Traditional IRA (always allowed) and immediately convert it to a Roth. It’s a legal loophole to get the tax-free growth you’re after! (This is a more advanced move, so we’ll cover the step-by-step details in a future post 😀.)

🏦 THE TRANSFER TROUBLE: MOVING YOUR MONEY AROUND

Changing Jobs? Here’s Your Playbook:

Roll Over to Your New Employer’s 401(k):
1. Keeps everything in one place
2. Let’s you take loans if the plan allows
3. But you’re stuck with their investment menu
Roll Over to an IRA (The Fan Favorite):
1. Unlimited investment choices
2. Often lower fees
3. Consolidates all your old retirement accounts
Leave It Where It Is:
1. Only if the old plan has amazing funds or low fees

😬 Risk: It becomes financial clutter. An old 401(k) is like a gym membership you keep paying for but never use. You lose track of its performance, fees can creep up, and it never gets the attention it needs to grow properly. Sometimes less is more.

Pro Tip: Always do a direct rollover where the money moves between institutions without you touching it. Avoid taxes and penalties!

TLDR; 🔁 Direct Rollover Explained: This is the IRS-approved “handoff” method. Your old provider sends the money directly to your new IRA or 401(k). You never get a check in your name. If you do get a check, it’s an indirect rollover—you have 60 days to deposit it, and taxes are withheld! A direct rollover is the safe, penalty-free champion.

FINAL BELL: YOUR CHAMPIONSHIP DECISION

❝

REF’S FINAL CALL: “The bout is over, and what a fight it’s been! But this isn’t a winner-take-all match. Judge, it’s time for your scorecards!”

YOUR WINNING STRATEGY:

Let the 401(k) take Round 1: Get the full employer match—that’s non-negotiable free money
Tag in the IRA for Round 2: Open a Roth IRA and max it out for control and tax-free growth. Aside: This is also a perfect account to open, especially if you have been wanting to start investing in the market.
Finish strong with the 401(k): If you’ve maxed your IRA and still have cash, go back and contribute more to your 401(k).

Consolidate your empire: Roll over any old 401(k)s into your IRA, or if you are changing jobs, roll the old 401(k) into your new employer’s plan.

☝️ Ready to Execute Your Decision?

You’ve judged the contenders and have your winning strategy. Now let Luci help you optimize the money you use every day by finding your own personalized credit card.

Bringing It Home 🏡

See? Not so complicated after all. You’re now more retirement-savvy than most people, and Future You is already celebrating. 🍻

Until next time, may your contributions be high and your fees be low! 🧑‍🚀

Instead of wondering how you’ll afford retirement, Future You will be on a beach somewhere—thanks to present you.. 🏖️

— Mitch @ Luci Money Moves

And so the match ends :)

‎Luci: Fun Personal Finance

‎Level Up Your Finances with Luci! Luci is the revolutionary mobile app that makes learning about money fun and engaging! Ditch the boring textbooks and dive into a world of interactive mini-games designed to boost your financial knowledge. Here's what makes Luci unique: Addictive Mini-Games: Lear…

apps.apple.com/us/app/luci-fun-personal-finance/id6739983865?utm_source=lucimoneymoves.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=ballin-on-a-budget-how-to-travel-without-breaking-the-bank

PS: Feeling unsure about any of this? We’ve got your back. Just reply to this email with your questions!

Reply

or to participate.